| Year | Record | Finish, Division | RS | RA | Age (1=oldest) | High OPS | Low RA | Attendance | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Year 1 | 22-28 (.440) | 3rd (16 GB), Eastern | 228 (8/16) | 228 (9/16) | 23.9 (13/16) | Statistics | Results | Aeschylus | (1.019) | W Shakespeare | (5.00) | 250,799 (13/16) |
| Year 2 | 24-26 (.480) | 3rd (6 GB), Eastern | 220 (10/16) | 206 (6/16) | 24.8 (9/16) | Statistics | Results | Aeschylus | (1.040) | Voltaire | (3.54) | 569,046 (8/16) |
| Year 3 | 27-24 (.529) | 2nd (2.5 GB), Eastern | 238 (7/16) | 194 (3/16) | 24.5 (10/16) | Statistics | Results | A Ludden | (0.913) | O Wilde | (3.66) | 733,181 (8/16) |
| Year 4 | 32-18 (.640) | 1st, Eastern | 251 (3/16) | 199 (4/16) | 25.2 (10/16) | Statistics | Results | A Chekhov | (1.136) | O Wilde | (3.34) | 945,189 (2/16) |
| Year 5 | 27-23 (.540) | 3rd (9 GB), Eastern | 239 (8/16) | 207 (8/16) | 26.2 (4/16) | Statistics | Results | A Chekhov | (1.011) | O Wilde | (2.47) | 1,042,280 (3/16) |
| Year 6 | 20-30 (.400) | 4th (15 GB), Eastern | 197 (12/16) | 236 (11/16) | 25.5 (6/16) | Statistics | Results | A Ludden | (0.928) | Voltaire | (4.29) | 956,938 (5/16) |
| Year 7 | 25-25 (.500) | T3rd (10 GB), Eastern | 173 (15/16) | 220 (8/16) | 26.1 (6/16) | Statistics | Results | A Chekhov | (0.985) | O Wilde | (4.52) | 983,529 (2/16) |
| Year 8 | 29-21 (.580) | T1st, Eastern | 213 (11/16) | 209 (6/16) | 26.2 (T2/16) | Statistics | Results | A Chekhov | (1.117) | O Wilde | (3.27) | 927,667 (6/16) |
| Year 9 | 21-29 (.420) | T4th (7 GB), Eastern | 180 (16/16) | 205 (6/16) | 27.1 (1/16) | Statistics | Results | A Miller | (0.867) | A Robinson | (3.10) | 934,552 (5/16) |
| Year 10 | 21-29 (.420) | 5th (7 GB), Eastern | 203 (10/16) | 273 (16/16) | 26.8 (1/16) | Statistics | Results | A Miller | (0.912) | A Robinson | (4.93) | 857,933 (6/16) |
| Year 11 | 12-38 (.240) | 5th (22 GB), Eastern | 144 (16/16) | 295 (16/16) | 26.0 (4/16) | Statistics | Results | A Chekhov | (0.859) | A Wilson | (5.73) | 465,830 (16/16) |
| Year 12 | 23-27 (.460) | 3rd (14 GB), Eastern | 151 (16/16) | 206 (7/16) | 24.4 (T11/16) | Statistics | Results | Moby | (0.704) | D Seuss | (2.71) | 448,971 (15/16) |
| Year 13 | 14-36 (.280) | 5th (19 GB), Eastern | 173 (14/16) | 295 (16/16) | 21.4 (16/16) | Statistics | Results | L Hansberry | (1.006) | S Stallone | (4.45) | 367,111 (16/16) |
| Year 14 | 21-29 (.420) | 3rd (12 GB), Eastern | 199 (10/16) | 233 (13/16) | 22.5 (16/16) | Statistics | Results | H Pinter | (0.950) | S Stallone | (3.04) | 492,524 (14/16) |
| Year 15 | 25-25 (.500) | T3rd (7 GB), Eastern | 196 (11/16) | 209 (11/16) | 22.8 (T14/16) | Statistics | Results | J Anouilh | (0.848) | K Frederik IX | (3.97) | 681,974 (12/16) |
| Year 16 | 21-29 (.420) | 5th (12 GB), Eastern | 199 (10/16) | 230 (12/16) | 22.7 (15/16) | Statistics | Results | D Fo | (0.994) | V Hugo | (3.89) | 626,445 (12/16) |
| Year 17 | 29-21 (.580) | 2nd (1 GB), Eastern | 219 (10/16) | 191 (2/16) | 26.1 (4/16) | Statistics | Results | H Pinter | (0.953) | M McAleese | (2.69) | 1,107,466 (3/16) |
| Year 18 | 32-18 (.640) | 1st, Eastern | 220 (8/16) | 149 (1/16) | 26.4 (6/16) | Statistics | Results | H Pinter | (1.021) | V Hugo | (2.22) | 1,023,605 (2/16) |
| Year 19 | 34-16 (.680) | 1st, Eastern | 222 (7/16) | 153 (1/16) | 27.0 (T2/16) | Statistics | Results | H Pinter | (0.915) | V Hugo | (2.37) | 1,240,391 (1/16) |
| Year 20 | 36-14 (.720) | 1st, Eastern | 258 (2/16) | 167 (1/16) | 26.8 (3/16) | Statistics | Results | D Fo | (1.076) | M McAleese | (2.85) | 1,216,904 (1/16) |
| Year 21 | 28-22 (.560) | 3rd (1.5 GB), Eastern | 199 (10/16) | 148 (1/16) | 27.4 (3/16) | Statistics | Results | D Fo | (0.923) | V Hugo | (2.04) | 1,042,215 (3/16) |
| Year 22 | 32-18 (.640) | 2nd (1 GB), Eastern | 203 (10/16) | 154 (2/16) | 27.7 (2/16) | Statistics | Results | Face | (1.093) | SR Leonard | (2.11) | 1,118,522 (2/16) |
| Year 23 | 30-20 (.600) | 2nd (1 GB), Eastern | 212 (9/16) | 155 (1/16) | 27.7 (1/16) | Statistics | Results | Face | (1.125) | V Hugo | (1.88) | 1,046,176 (3/16) |
| Year 24 | 32-18 (.640) | 1st, Eastern | 257 (1/16) | 186 (T5/16) | 28.5 (1/16) | Statistics | Results | Face | (1.127) | V Hugo | (2.37) | 1,034,502 (3/16) |
| Year 25 | 33-17 (.660) | 1st, Eastern | 215 (6/16) | 148 (3/16) | 28.2 (2/16) | Statistics | Results | J Orton | (1.084) | V Hugo | (1.86) | 1,057,406 (3/16) |
| Year 26 | 25-25 (.500) | 2nd (13 GB), Eastern | 224 (6/16) | 198 (8/16) | 28.8 (2/16) | Statistics | Results | Face | (0.972) | V Hugo | (2.60) | 1,006,825 (4/16) |
| Year 27 | 23-27 (.460) | 4th (17 GB), Eastern | 199 (T8/16) | 187 (7/16) | 27.1 (T2/16) | Statistics | Results | Baraka | (0.915) | R Bolt | (3.72) | 766,179 (9/16) |
| Year 28 | 24-26 (.480) | T3rd (13 GB), Eastern | 197 (10/16) | 216 (9/16) | 26.6 (4/16) | Statistics | Results | S Pilgrim | (0.868) | Adele | (4.16) | 672,518 (12/16) |
| Year 29 | 21-29 (.420) | 4th (15 GB), Eastern | 206 (10/16) | 260 (T12/16) | 25.1 (T10/16) | Statistics | Results | Baraka | (1.040) | Adele | (5.61) | 684,397 (15/16) |
| Year 30 | 27-23 (.540) | 2nd (12 GB), Eastern | 231 (T5/16) | 222 (10/16) | 25.6 (8/16) | Statistics | Results | Baraka | (0.916) | A Lavigne | (2.59) | 730,337 (9/16) |
| Year 31 | 16-34 (.320) | 5th (13 GB), Eastern | 193 (14/16) | 270 (14/16) | 24.3 (T12/16) | Statistics | Results | T Letts | (0.833) | R de Valle-Inclan | (5.82) | 552,705 (16/16) |
| Year 32 | 16-34 (.320) | 5th (19 GB), Eastern | 186 (15/16) | 243 (11/16) | 23.7 (15/16) | Statistics | Results | T Rattigan | (0.879) | J Larson | (3.98) | 504,559 (15/16) |
| Year 33 | 20-30 (.400) | 3rd (12 GB), Eastern | 189 (14/16) | 264 (15/16) | 24.6 (T11/16) | Statistics | Results | Baraka | (0.923) | J Larson | (5.22) | 724,215 (12/16) |
| Year 34 | 22-28 (.440) | 3rd (13 GB), Eastern | 207 (9/16) | 224 (T10/16) | 22.1 (13/16) | Statistics | Results | G Villiers | (0.961) | J Larson | (4.84) | 634,651 (13/16) |
| Year 35 | 24-26 (.480) | 2nd (7 GB), Eastern | 168 (16/16) | 202 (10/16) | 24.0 (12/16) | Statistics | Results | G Villiers | (0.875) | O Hammerstein II | (3.98) | 773,392 (9/16) |
| Year 36 | 27-23 (.540) | 3rd (11 GB), Eastern | 242 (5/16) | 206 (9/16) | 24.4 (11/16) | Statistics | Results | Riou | (1.025) | O Hammerstein II | (3.94) | 866,307 (7/16) |
| Year 37 | 30-20 (.600) | 2nd (1 GB), Eastern | 251 (8/16) | 169 (3/16) | 25.6 (T6/16) | Statistics | Results | C Tourneur | (1.026) | O Hammerstein II | (3.91) | 996,593 (4/16) |
| Year 38 | 32-18 (.640) | T2nd (1 GB), Eastern | 270 (2/16) | 163 (5/16) | 26.4 (T1/16) | Statistics | Results | G Villiers | (1.090) | T Kyd | (3.12) | 1,171,424 (2/16) |
| Year 39 | 33-17 (.660) | 1st, Eastern | 307 (1/16) | 219 (11/16) | 26.7 (T2/16) | Statistics | Results | G Villiers | (1.026) | O Hammerstein II | (3.51) | 1,045,725 (5/16) |
| Year 40 | 32-18 (.640) | 1st, Eastern | 259 (1/16) | 189 (8/16) | 25.9 (6/16) | Statistics | Results | G Villiers | (1.081) | O Hammerstein II | (2.79) | 969,111 (7/16) |
| Year 41 | 36-14 (.720) | 1st, Eastern | 203 (T6/16) | 140 (2/16) | 25.7 (4/16) | Statistics | Results | G Villiers | (0.836) | K Capek | (2.12) | 1,120,372 (3/16) |
| Year 42 | 31-19 (.620) | 2nd (4 GB), Eastern | 205 (9/16) | 162 (3/16) | 26.6 (1/16) | Statistics | Results | G Villiers | (1.096) | K Capek | (3.45) | 1,065,244 (3/16) |
| Year 43 | 31-19 (.620) | 1st, Eastern | 222 (4/16) | 181 (4/16) | 27.0 (1/16) | Statistics | Results | Zack | (0.999) | O Hammerstein II | (3.67) | 1,083,911 (3/16) |
| Year 44 | 26-24 (.520) | 3rd (5 GB), Eastern | 201 (10/16) | 197 (6/16) | 27.1 (T1/16) | Statistics | Results | Zack | (0.841) | O Hammerstein II | (3.06) | 980,161 (5/16) |
| Year 45 | 21-29 (.420) | T4th (9 GB), Eastern | 240 (4/16) | 258 (15/16) | 27.9 (T2/16) | Statistics | Results | J Burgoyne | (0.864) | C de Bergerac | (4.95) | 754,044 (10/16) |
| Year 46 | 21-29 (.420) | 3rd (13 GB), Eastern | 199 (T10/16) | 266 (16/16) | 26.1 (7/16) | Statistics | Results | A Pinkerton | (0.955) | B Gelfand | (5.13) | 586,564 (13/16) |
| Year 47 | 24-26 (.480) | 3rd (8 GB), Eastern | 194 (12/16) | 243 (14/16) | 23.9 (11/16) | Statistics | Results | J Lyly | (0.879) | B Gelfand | (3.45) | 597,154 (14/16) |
| Year 48 | 17-33 (.340) | 4th (13 GB), Eastern | 171 (16/16) | 269 (15/16) | 23.1 (15/16) | Statistics | Results | F Loesser | (0.842) | R Parker | (5.61) | 498,103 (15/16) |
Playoff history:
| Year 4 | Broadway defeated Seattle, 4-3; Broadway defeated Terra, 4-2 |
| Year 8 | San Jose defeated Broadway, 4-0 |
| Year 17 | Industry defeated Broadway, 4-2 |
| Year 18 | Broadway defeated Industry, 4-1; Broadway defeated San Jose, 4-3 |
| Year 19 | Broadway defeated Stamford, 4-3; Seattle defeated Broadway, 4-1 |
| Year 20 | Broadway defeated Stamford, 4-0; Seattle defeated Broadway, 4-1 |
| Year 23 | Broadway defeated Industry, 4-0; Kratovo defeated Broadway, 4-2 |
| Year 24 | Brussels defeated Broadway, 4-2 |
| Year 25 | Milan defeated Broadway, 4-1 |
| Year 39 | Stockholm defeated Broadway, 4-1 |
| Year 40 | Broadway defeated Stockholm, 4-3; San Jose defeated Broadway, 4-2 |
| Year 41 | Seattle defeated Broadway, 4-0 |
| Year 42 | Brooklyn defeated Broadway, 4-1 |
| Year 43 | Broadway defeated Berkeley, 4-3; Seattle defeated Broadway, 4-0 |
| Franchise single-season records: | Franchise leaders, hitting (min. 300 PA): | Franchise leaders, pitching (min. 150 IP): |
|
|
|
Players who have played for Broadway (Statistics, Drafted players):